Dam floods · Dams · Floods · Monsoon

Central India Heavy Downpour brings back nightmare memories of 2019 Chambal Scare

In a rather unusual development, no less than twenty districts in contiguous areas of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Gujarat had extremely high rainfall in the 48 hours ending at 830 am on Aug 23, 2020. Three of these districts had over 250 mm rainfall in this period, four others had between 200-250 mm, six each between 150-200 and 100-150 and one between 90-100 mm. This contiguous area broadly drains Mahi river to the West, Chambal to the North, Narmada to the South and Betwa to the East. These rivers, thus are now getting heavy flows, and will continue to get for the next few days, some of it from Chambal and Betwa will also end up in Yamuna and Ganga. It reminded one of the nightmarish memories of Sept 2019 when Gandhi Sagar Dam faced existential crisis and the flood peak downstream reached upto Farakka Dam, as CWC Flood forecasting director Sharad Chandra said in a television discussion recently.

Impacts of this massive rainfall is already being experienced and continues as we write this. At least three Monitoring Sites of Central Water Commission Flood Forecasting Program has already crossed their highest flood levels (HFL), all in Chambal basin. In Narmada basin, Indira Sagar Dam has seen massive flood inflow that has already reached 19250 cumecs, or 6.8 lakh cusecs. In Mahi & Betwa Basins too all the dams are experiencing massive inflows, for more details, see below.

SANDRP Map (with thanks to Siddharth Agarwal for helping Bhim Singh Rawat to put this and the above feature map together)

Citizen Voice Senior journalist and author Shri Abhilash Khandekar wrote on Aug 22, 2020: ” I am in Mahalaxmi Nagar Indore today. All roads and streets here are full of water as there’s just no provision of drainage system anywhere. Almost knee-deep water. Also, because no space is left for natural percolation of water. Entire land has been paved in most areas of Indore colonies in 74 Scheme, Vijay Nagar and near by colonies. What Mr Atul Sheth, an engineer and planner, has said applies not only to Kesharbag Rd, but all over the city. And what about elected representatives, Mayor/ Corporators/ Chief Engineer, City Planners? Who will make them responsible? And we like to call it ‘Development’ …Wah Indore Wah!”

Chambal River Basin The impacts are most starkly visible in terms of the HFL crossing by at least three rivers already, bringing back the memory of the flood disaster of Sept 2019 when Gandhi Sagar dam came close to over topping. CWC tweeted late on the night of Sept 14, 2019: “As informed by Mr Bharat Gosavi, CE Dam Safety minutes back, Gandhisagar dam, MP is in great crisis, inflow 16 lakh cusec & outflow 5.0 lakh cusec, dam already full, going for some big overtopping, all disaster management agencies must be activated accordingly.” The crisis was so severe that the Cabinet Secretary called a meeting of National Crisis Management Committee to discuss that issue on a Sunday, on Sept 15, 2019.[i]

The inflows into Gandhi Sagar Dam on Chambal River till 1300 hrs on Aug 22, 2020 was just 30 cumecs, has already reached 3322 cumecs, or 110 times higher levels and is forecast to touch 6000 cumecs. The water level at the dam on Aug 20 was 395.47 m (FRL 399.9 m), with reservoir live capacity 61% full. It went up to 396.03 m by 0800 hrs on Aug 23. This means there is some storage space in the reservoir.

Downstream Ranapratap Sagar Reservoir was 47% full on Aug 20 with water level at 348.53 m (FRL: 352.81 m), it rose to 348.85 m by 0800 hrs on Aug 23. The inflows here have already jumped from 70 cumecs on Aug 21 to 440 cumecs on Aug 23, and will take big jump once Gandhi Sagar is full.

Three different CWC flood monitoring sites crossed their previous Highest Flood level on three different rivers, all in Chambal basin:

1. At Palwa, on Chamla River in Ujjain Dist, old HFL of 101.09 m crossed at 1730 hrs on Aug 22, 2020. It reached a new HFL of 102.93 (huge 1.84 m above the previous HFL) m and stayed at that level between 0500 and 0800 hrs on Aug 23, 2020. Over 24 hours after crossing HFL, it remains above HFL as we write this. Previous HFL was crossed on Aug 9, 2019, as per information provided (for all three sites) by CWC FF Director Shri Sharad Chandra to SANDRP. Chamla River confluences with Chambal just upstream of Nagda town. Water level here came below HFL only by 0100 hrs on Aug 24. So water level remained above HFL for 31.5 hours.

2. At Sonkatch site on Kalisindh River in Dewas Dist, the old HFL of 96.83 m (reached on Sept 8, 2019) was crossed at 1200 hrs on Aug 22. New High of 97.97 m was reached at 1500 hrs and level came down below old HFL at 1600 hrs. So new HFL at this site is now 1.14 m above old HFL and remained above HFL for 4 hours.

3. At Astha on Parwati River in Sehore Dist, MP old HFL of 100.32 m (reached on Sept 8, 2019) crossed at 0900 hrs on Aug 22, 2020. New High level of 102.4 m, 2.08 m above old HFL was at 1200 hrs and remained at that level for about four hours. The water level came down below the old HFL at 0200 hrs on Aug 23, 2020. Thus the water level here remained above HFL for 17 hours.

This crossing of the 2019 levels at three sites already sounds ominous.

In addition, water level jumped up by about eight meters at several monitoring sites, some of them are listed here.

  • Dhareri At this site (HFL 482.208 m) in Ujjain district on Chambal river, water level was at 468.35 m at 2100 hrs on Aug 21. It reached a level of 481.14 m by 0000 hrs on 2308, taking a huge jump of 12.79 m.

Water Level at flood forecasting site at Dholpur (UP) on Chambal River started rising and is expected to cross the danger level on Aug 24 night. This is basically due to Parwati and other tributaries meeting Chambal downstream of Kota city, since the hydrograph at Kota City is stable, yet to start rising as outflows from upstream dams complex have not yet started.

Narmada Basin To the south of the region covered by the 20 districts is the Narmada Basin. Here the biggest reservoir of the country, Indira Sagar Dam has seen huge jump in live storage in recent days. In fact, the inflow into the dam has jumped to 19250 cumecs or massive 6.8 lakh cusecs & the water level has reached 260.34 m, less than 1.8 m below FRL. Inflow into the downstream Sardar Sarovar has also gone up to 6000 cumecs or about 2.1 lakh cusecs. The water level has also taken a leap to 125.27 m on Aug 23 morning. The trouble with CWC inflow hydrographs is that most of them give incomplete information, very rarely do we find full hourly information including inflow, outflow-canal and outflow-river.

Betwa Basin To the East of the high downpour region is the Betwa basin. Here the Rajghat dam had inflow of about 1300 cumecs on Aug 21, which was forecast to jump over five fold to 6605 cumecs. Outflow was expected to jump from zero to 6806 cumecs.

At downstream Matatila Dam, water outflow was expected to jump from zero to 8148 cumecs. At Mohana Flood Forecasting site of CWC, water level increased by over 5 mts in 9 hours on Aug 23 to 116.56 m from 111.51 m at 1200 hours. The flow projects at Rajghat have started reducing.

Mahi Basin To the West of the mapped districts, is the Mahi River Basin, flowing from Rajasthan and MP to Gujarat. As per IMD’s River Basin Rainfall Map for Aug 23 (24 hrs ending at 0830 hrs on Aug 23), Mahi basin as a whole received massive 103.7 mm rainfall in 24 hours, 1507% above normal.

At Mahi Bajaj Sagar dam in Banswara district in Rajasthan (live storage capacity 1.711 BCM, it was 43% full on Aug 20[ii]), the inflow jumped in just twelve hours from practically Zero to 5680 cumecs by 1200 hrs on Aug 22. In next 24 hours, it jumped further to 11688 cumecs and to 13348 cumecs in next one hour. The dam water level went up from 273.95 m at 1200 hrs on Aug 22, to 278.65 m by 1100 hrs and 280.5 m by 1800 hrs on Aug 23. That is just one m away from FRL. ANI tweet below shows the dam with 16 gates open around 8 pm on Aug 23, 2020.

The hydrograph below shows how within nine hours, water level at Borwa site in Ratlam district in Madhya Pradesh rose by 7 meters to 324.7 m at 0600 hrs on Aug 22.

As can be seen in the hydrograph below, the Anas PH-II site on Anas river, a tributary of Mahi, in Banswara district, the water level rose by a massive 14.8 m in about 18 hours ending at 1700 hrs on Aug 22.

At downstream Kadana dam in Mehsana district in Gujarat (live storage capacity 1.472 BCM, it was 25% full on Aug 20), the inflow was below 100 cumecs till early hours on Aug 22, it went upto 8919 cumecs 0600 hrs on Aug 23. Dam water level has gone up by huge 8 mts in 36 hrs ending at 1800 hrs on 2308. by 2408 morning, water level was 126.8 m, within a meter of FRL of 127.71 m.

At Somkamla Amba Dam on Som, a tributary, in Dungarpur district of Rajasthan, inflow went up from 35 cumecs at 0600 hrs of 2208 to 740 (21 fold increase) by 1000 hrs on 2308. The water level at the dam at 213 m is just half a m away from the FRL.

There is also Panam dam on another tributary of Mahi river in Gujarat, here inflow increased from 36 cumecs on Aug 23 morning to 60 fold higher figure of 2020 cumecs next morning.

In Conclusion Its scary that all the sites that saw the water level cross in Chambal basin on Aug 22, 2020 had their HFL reached only last year and these have been breached by huge 1.14 to 2.08 m. Secondly, the dams in these four basins (Chambal, Narmada, Mahi and Betwa) are almost full and soon they will start releasing all the inflows downstream. Unfortunately, neither rule curves, nor inflow, Canal-outflow & River-outflow for all the dams are available on hourly basis even for the dams that are under inflow forecasting of CWC FF.  This is essential requirement to ascertain how they are being operated. The National Disaster Management Authority held a National Conference on the issue of reservoir operation in flood season in Oct 2019[iii], soon after the 2020 monsoon, but we see no real improvement in the operation of dams this year or even in sharing of information about the dams.

The information that this region is going to receive heavy rainfall was available at least two days in advance. For example, this weekly bulletin from India Meteorological Department bulletin of Aug 20, 2020 had clearly forecast heavy rainfall in MP (Aug 21), Rajasthan & Gujarat (Aug 22-23): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhvOfloCMyI&t=27s). Did we see any advance action plan from the dam operators and basin wise coordination in any of the basin, either when the forecast was available or even when information of the actual rainfall was available? Does the CWC FF take into account the actual rainfall information across the catchment of the specific dam and assess the possible inflow schedule and accordingly plan the outflows advisory and flood advisory? The answer is clearly no.

In changing climate, we may experience repeated events of such nature, as we did in 2019 and again 2020. If we do not change the way we operate our dams, we are bound to face more flood disasters.

Himanshu Thakkar (ht.sandrp@gmail.com)


[i] https://sandrp.in/2019/09/24/man-made-national-crisis-that-gandhi-sagar-dam-faced-in-sept-2019/

[ii] http://cwc.gov.in/sites/default/files/20082020-full-bul.pdf

[iii] https://ndma.gov.in/images/pdf/workshop-flood-mgmt.pdf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.