CWC - Central Water Commission · Dam Induced Flood Disaster · Ganga

Why are Patna & Bhagalpur facing unprecedented floods on India’s 75th independence day?

As India prepares to celebrate 75th Independence day on August 15, 2021, large parts of Bihar along the Ganga river, including Patna (flood water entered colonies near Ganga in Patna) and Bhagalpur are preparing to face unprecedented floods. In fact, Central Water Commission’s (CWC) flood monitoring site at Hathidah in Patna district crossed the HIGHEST FLOOD LEVEL (HFL) of 43.17 m at 0300 hours in early morning on Aug 13, 2021. The water level is already at 43.33 m at 1300 hrs on Aug 14. It is forecast to reach 43.45 m by 0800 on independence day still with rising trend. This is apparent from the CWC hydrograph of this site shown above.

Monsoon Updates LIVE: Flood water enters residential areas near Ganga River in Patna; heavy rains in Northeast, West Bengal
Floodwaters entered colonies near Ganga in Patna (Photo India Today)

CWC FF tweet about severe inundation around Hathidah in Patna dist in Bihar along Ganga on Aug 13, 2021:
https://twitter.com/CWCOfficial_FF/status/1426126406136655879

At upstream Gandhighat in Patna, water level is already at 50.38 m, within 14 cm of its HFL (50.52 m), the CWC forecast says it will be within 11 cms of HFL in the morning of independence day, still showing rising trend, see CWC flood hydrograph below.

At downstream Bhagalpur, the Ganga river water level is forecast to reach 34.7. m, just 2 centimetres within its HFL of 34.72 m by 1600 hrs on Independence Day. It is already at 34.53 m at 1100 hrs on Aug 14, as can be seen from CWC flood hydrograph below.

Flooded Colonies of Bhagalpur Photo by Ruchi Shree on Aug 14, 2021
Lalbag Professors’ Colony of Tilka Majhi University in Nathnagar area of Bhagalpur Photo by Ruchi Shree on Aug 13 2021

A little further upstream at Ballia in Uttar Pradesh (see CWC flood forecasting hydro graph below), the water level is at 60.25 m still with rising trend, just 14 cms lower than its HFL of 60.39 m. CWC has forecast that this will now go down to 60.15 m at 0800 hrs on Aug 15, but let us see how correct that forecast is.

CWC FF tweet about severe flooding along Ganga at Ballia on Aug 13, 2021:
https://twitter.com/CWCOfficial_FF/status/1426128006347575300

Why these unprecedented Ganga Flood levels? This could be largely seen as the effect of huge rainfall and floods in upstream Ganga basin areas of Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan during Aug 3-6, which became a flood peak along Yamuna that is now traveling downstream, releases from a number of large dams in those areas also contributing to the flood peak.

There is no doubt that flood peak is playing a role in Ganga crossing HFL at Hathidah now. But is that explanation good enough? The fact is the water level did not reach the HFL levels at almost any of the numerous sites along Yamuna (with the exception of Auraiya, possibly because of its close proximity with the point where Chambal brought the flood waters to Yamuna) or Ganga upstream of Hathidah and the sites mentioned above.

The Farakka factor: Farakka Influence Zone There is another factor that is playing a role here. The name of that factor is FARAKKA dam on the Ganga downstream from Bihar. Farakka dam, as Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has said many times earlier, is acting like a bottle neck, leading to accumulation of hundreds of millions of cubic meters of debris (including silt, sand, boulders and other materials that the river brings) on the river beds each year. This has led to huge drainage congestion along the river, reducing the carrying capacity of the river massively. It is this then which does not allow the quick drainage of the flood peak, a problem that the river upstream from what we can call Farakka Influence Zone (FIZ) does not face, but the river flow starts slowing down in FIZ.

As can be seen from CWC’s flood hydrograph for Farakka above, the Ganga water level at Farakka went above the danger level of 22.25 m in evening hours of Aug 5, 2021 and has shown rising trend since then. This level is likely to remain above danger level till close to the end of the monsoon season, as is normally the case.

2017 Union Govt Committee on Role of Farakka: CWC had no data What is this impact of FIZ on the river and how far this zone is extended is a subject of investigation. Following unprecedented Bihar floods of Aug 2016 (see below for details) the issue of role of Farakka had arisen. On request of Bihar CM Nitish Kumar, the Union Government had set up a committee in Sept 2017. However, Central Water Commission, which is supposed to be repository of all the Ganga silt and flood related information, did not have ANY pre-Farakka information (which is key to understand the role of Farakka) and not even most of the post Farakka information, so there was no way to convincingly arrive at the answers to questions related Farakka Influence Zone. This author was a member of the committee. The committee was wound up with a split report: Bihar Govt appointed 5 members of the committee submitting a detailed report about the key issues, information non-availability and so on; the CWC appointed members submitting a report that could not answer any of the issues raised. Because of CWC’s inability to provide basic information required for the work of the committee, committee could not come to any useful consensus conclusions.

Aug 2016: Unprecedented Bihar floods The unprecedented flood levels along Ganga in Bihar this year is a repeat of what happened almost exactly five years ago, in Aug 2016[i]. That time, as SANDRP wrote then, there was a role of upstream (water release from Ban Sagar Dam in Madhya Pradesh in upstream Ganga Basin) and a downstream (Farakka) factor. That time too the Ganga water levels along Ballia, Gandhighat, Hathidah and Bhagalapur had breached the HFL levels, as it is happening this year.

This seems to indicate that huge, wide spread areas along Ganga upstream of Farakka, possibly right upto Ballia will continue to face such unprecedented floods every few years, possibly with increasing frequency and intensity under climate change induced rainfall pattern, as long as we are unable to convincingly diagnose or solve the impact of Farakka. In fact Farakka increases the floods along the Ganga even in normal monsoon years. We hope Bihar CM Nitish Kumar, Bihar Water Resources Department and others concerned will raise this issue again as Bihar seems to be the biggest sufferers of FIZ.

Himanshu Thakkar (ht.sandrp@gmail.com)

POST SCRIPT:
1. Aug 19 2021: Officials in the state of Bihar in eastern India report flooding in 15 districts affecting 2716 villages has affected 2.7 million people. The Ganges River is at record levels in Bhagalpur and Patna Districts. Rivers across the state are above the danger mark in 26 locations. The affected districts are: Muzaffarpur, Darbhanga, Khagaria, Saharsa, Patna, Vaishali, Bhojpur, Lakhisarai, Bhagalpur, Saran, Buxar, Begusarai, Katihar, Munger and Samastipur.
https://floodlist.com/asia/india-floods-bihar-august-2021-update

END NOTES:

[i] https://sandrp.in/2016/08/23/a-tale-of-two-dams-is-bihars-unprecedented-flood-an-avoidable-man-made-disaster/

One thought on “Why are Patna & Bhagalpur facing unprecedented floods on India’s 75th independence day?

  1. Sir, I don’t know about other sensitive Indians but due to certain reasons, for last 5 years or so, looking at the policies towards environment and Socio-economic conditions of the majority of our population, I don’t believe in independence day celebration any longer. It’s like more or less, building a monument after the death of democracy that we used to know earlier, is ongoing. I don’t know how come our union government spends billions of rupees on such celebrations while 70 to 80 percent people are left to fend for themselves after covid pandemic and worst economic crisis.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.