SANDRP Blog Little for Bundelkhand, lot for contractors in Ken Betwa river-linkThe official executive summary of the Detailed Project Report of KBLRP on NWDA website says: “The main objective of the Ken-Betwa link project is to make available water to water deficit areas of upper Betwa basin through substitution from the surplus waters of Ken basin.” Upper Betwa basin (Raisen and Vidisha districts of MP) is not in Bundelkhand. So KBLRP is essentially facilitating export of water from drought prone Bundelkhand to area outside Bundelkhand, which, in fact is well endowed with over 900 mm of average annual rainfall.
The DPR further says, a third o the surplus water will be utilized for “enroute irrigation of 0.60 lakh ha. in the districts of Tikamgarh and Chhatarpur of MP and Mahoba & Jhansi of U.P.” The claim in the minutes of Expert Appraisal Committee meeting of Dec 30, 2016 that “It is proposed to provide irrigation facility in 6,35,661 ha of area in Panna, Chhatarpur, Tikamgarh Districts of Madhya Pradesh and Banda, Mahoba and Jhansi Districts in Uttar Pradesh” needs to be put in context here. Firstly, this claim is far in excess of what the presumed surplus water can irrigate.
EAC against entertaining ‘anti-development’ representationsThe expert appraisal committee (EAC) on river valley and hydel projects of the Union Environment Ministry has decided “not to take any cognizance of such representations” received by its members. In its Dec. 30, 2016 meeting, the committee concluded that once a project proposal reaches the EAC for appraisal, it has crossed the stage of public consultation and “the EAC should not go back in time, and should not reopen it, by entertaining unsubstantiated representations received from the people”.
The EAC noted that in case of any clarification regarding action taken on such representations under the RTI Act, the EAC prescribed that a standard reply “action has been taken in accordance with the decisions taken in the 1st meeting of the EAC for River Valley and HEP on 30.12.2016” should suffice. “It was also felt that many of the objections raised are repetitive. Many such kind of representations have an anti-development attitude so that the projects are kept on hold or delayed. This has financial implications to the developers in particular and to the nation in general.
The committee emphasized that relevant ministries scrutinised every aspect of a project and proposed it for final appraisal only when all details were in place. If not satisfied that public consultation had been completed properly, the EAC said it could ask the project promoter to do the needful. The committee also made allowance for representations with “new points” and “grave consequences” on which comments from project proponents could be sought. The EAC considered 13 projects in its December 30 meeting and cleared eight of them.
Environmental activists, however, pointed out the impracticality of the contention that representations should be restricted to the 30-day public consultation window. Sripad Dharmadhikari also, in his blog has mentions various reasons to counter the EAC’s suspicious justifications. He also says that the fact that a body which is supposed to represent the environmental perspective displays such an attitude is the biggest critique of the EAC and the environmental clearance process that it is a part of. The newly constituted MOEF’s EAC on River Valley Projects has in their very first meeting shown anti people, anti democratic and anti environment attitude.
According to just released Living Planet Report 2016, the loss of habitat is prime reason behind declining of wildlife species found in and around wetlands, rivers and lakes due to increasing fragmentation, pollution and destruction of these ecosystems. Data in report also underlines that the global water crisis is real and water requirements worldwide will go up by 40 per cent by 2030.
The report emphasizes habitats based on rivers, wetlands and lakes command high economic, cultural, aesthetic, recreational and educational value. At the same time, these habitats are challenging to conserve because they are strongly affected by the modification of their river basins as well as by direct impacts from dams, pollution, invasive aquatic species and unsustainable water extractions.
Further, fresh water based habitats often are beyond administrative and political boundaries; warranting the extra effort for collaborative forms of protection. The report refers to several studies which have found that species living in freshwater habitats are faring worse than terrestrial species.
The report notes that Brazil, Russia, India, China and the United States (a different BRICS) account for nearly half of the planet’s total bio-capacity. These few countries function as global bio-capacity hubs as they are among the primary exporters of resources to the other countries. This results in great pressure on ecosystems in these countries, contributing to habitat loss.
This account summarizes the key findings of the report in context of threats and impacts over fresh water sources and species.
Big Dams Ineffective & Destructive, Will Involved Villagers In Building Small Check Dams: CM JharkhandOn Oct 21 making an important statement during a meeting in Jharkhand CM Raghubar Das has said that State Government will not construct big dams and will go for smaller check dams. While addressing the Asanpahari villagers in naxal affected Kathi Kund, the CM also said that he was against big dams as they entail catastrophic and cascading impact on environment and local people. Admitting that big dams have not benefited the farmers, he criticized the former Congress Government for allowing construction of big dams.
The CM has also made another important announcement that villagers would be involved in the construction of smaller check dams to meet water need for irrigation. Announcing funding of 15 small water recharge ponds in every village, he also stated that villagers will be be financially assisted to develop their own plan for construction of check dams. He also urged villagers to produce electricity from Bio-Gas and use its by-product the sludge as manure in fields.
Jharkhand CM here is making an interesting CLEAR statement that big dams have not helped Jharkhand and they would prefer to go for smaller dams.
झारखंड में अब बनेगा छोटा डैममुख्यमंत्री ने काठीकुंड के उग्रवाद प्रभावित गांव आसनपहाड़ी में विशेष ग्रामसभा में कहा कि सरकार राज्य में अब बड़े डैम नहीं , चेकडैम बनायेगी. सरकार बड़े डैमों की पक्षधर नहीं है. उन्होंने कहा कि कैसे बड़े बांध का बजट हनुमान की पूंछ की तरह बढ़ता जा रहा है. कई योजनाएं दशकों से अधर में हैं. सीएम ने कहा की बड़े डैमों से इस राज्य के किसानों को फायदा नहीं हुआ. कांग्रेस के राज में बड़े-बड़े डैम बने. गांव हमारा डूबा, लेकिन फायदा बंगाल को होता रहा. अब सिंचाई की जरूरत को देखते हुए गांव के लोग फैसला लेंगे. चैकडेम कहां बनेगा, यह गांव के ही लोग तय करेंगे. अपनी जरूरत के हिसाब से वे योजना बनायेंगे. इंजीनियर भी रांची का नहीं, इसी इलाके का होगा. सीएम ने कहा : इस इलाके में बरसात कम नहीं होती. सारा पानी बंगाल से होकर समुद्र में चला जाता है. बोरा बांध बना कर भी गांव में पानी रोका जा सकता है. उन्होंने हर गांव में 15-15 डोभा बनाये जाने की भी घोषणा की. कहा कि इसका पैसा भी सरकार देगी. सीएम ने कहा की गांवों में अब गोबर बैंक बनाये जायेंगे, जहां गांव भर से गोबर उठाया जायेगा. गोबर गैस प्लांट में बिजली पैदा की जायेगी, जिससे स्ट्रीट लाइट जलेगी और जो अपशिष्ट बचेगा, उससे जैविक खाद बनाया जायेगा. गोमूत्र का भी उपयोग खाद में किया जायेगा.
HYDRO POWER
SANDRP Blog Amid repercussions, PM inaugurates 3 HEPsPM Modi, on Oct 18 has dedicated to nation 3 big hydro projects namely the 800 Mw Kol Dam, 520 Mw Parbati & 412Mw Rampur in Himachal. All these HEPs have been involved in several controversies right from the day of inception. These projects were given clearances in questionable manner and even have not gone through proper EIAs. The resultant impact on environment, Rivers, and local communities has been catastrophic. The projects have been facing prolong, unending protests & stiff resistance from locals. Here is a brief description of all three projects along with short description of damages they caused and community driven protest they have been facing. Also listen to a AIR discussion on hydro projects in India in view of the PM dedicating Himachal HEPs. The discussion included SANDRP coordinator and Kirtika Suneja of Economic Times. Please share your feedback and send it to others who may be interested.
It is worth mentioning that the first-ever Disaster Analysis & Management reportcompiled by the Himachal govt emphasises the high vulnerabilityof major parts of five districts of Kangra, Chamba, Hamirpur, Kullu and Mandi to earthquakes. The projects under discussion lie in the very districts mentioned in the report. It also points out that though the state is prone to many hazards, earthquakes can pose a serious challenge. Similarly, according the latest study confirms that there is accelerated glacial melting in all the river basinsof Chenab, Ravi, Beas, Sutlej. The the number of lakes has gone up in all the basins. In the Sutlej basin the number has remained stagnant at 391 in last two years, but one cannot overlook the fact that the number of lakes in the Sutlej basin rose from a mere 38 in 1994 to 390 in 2015. Raising alarm bells on unabated hydro projects in Himalaya, one more report concludes that of the 177 hydro projects located close to Himalayan glaciers over a fifth including many in India could be under flood threat caused by the outbursts of glacial lakes, European researchers have warned. Most of the sampled hydropower projects are in the Indian Himalayan states of Himachal, Uttarakhand and Sikkim, and some in Nepal and Bhutan.
Meanwhile, several Himachal NGOs under the aegis of Himdhara & Himalaya Niti Abhiyaan have sought moratorium on dams, mega hydro power projects. Urging PM to announce a green development package for Himachal instead of special industrial package being sought by everyone, the organisations said such development projects have reported high negative impact on local eco system, environment, river system, forest, triggered landslides, increased erratic weather pattern and negatively impacted agriculture and horticulture.
On the contrary, there are news reports claiming that Govt of India may override environment concerns to pursue hydro projects in Himalayan region. The report quotes a senior water ministry official saying as “It has been realized that we have lost a lot of time in developing hydropower in the northeast. We need to move fast to establish our right on water from rivers like Brahmaputra that are coming from China. There are some genuine environmental concerns but they are not more important than our country’s strategic concerns. This is the time to take hard decisions. Indeed, Himalayan rivers have also become the new flash pointin the bitter India-Pakistan conflict, providing the latest diplomatic weapon in PM Modi’s push to isolate Islamabad.
HimachalReturning Power to PeopleThe Kashang project is just one of many in Kinnaur which has led to the landscape being torn apart pieces of its hollowed mountains, sliding, cracking and quaking every other day. Little wonder that the people of the region welcomed the NGT judgment. For a people, who have paid the cost of this “development”, without ever being considered as “decision makers” in the process of planning and impact assessment, the NGT judgment validated their connection with their landscape and culture. A report by Himadhara.
J&KExamining hydro projects economy of the StateThe author of this piece could have calculated the power generated by all existing hydropower projects in the state (irrespective of ownership) and asked why this power should not be made available to the people of the state?
RIVERS
(A) An image showing the Gangetic dolphin in its wild habitat (photo credit: Kadambari Deshpande), (B) a dead Gangetic dolphin calf (notice the pinhole like eyes), and (C) the calf is 1 m long, and adults measure to 2.6 m (photo credits for B & C: Sushant Dey).
SANDRP BlogDo we care for river dolphins or their habitat?Nachiket Kelkar, in a Guest blog for SANDRP discusses the statement of Union Water Resources Minister Sushri Uma Bharti about Ganga Dolphins turning blind due to pollution.
GANGA NGT No one knows how many drains pollute GangaThe observation came after the CPCB told the NGT that there were 30 main drains which joined Ganga or its main tributaries like East Kali, Kosi and Ramganga falling in the segment from Haridwar and Unnao. However, UP Pollution Control Board claimed there were 172 drains, of which 150 directly joined Ganga and its tributaries. According to UP Jal Nigam, there were 172 drains out of which 83 terminated in the Ganga. The tribunal has asked MoEF, CPCB, UP state pollution board & Jal Nigam to clarify their stand on zero liquid discharge, online monitoring of effluents and discharge of waste in drains by industries releasing contaminants in Ganga. The Green Tribunal also has rapped UP govt for wasting crores of rupees of public money on Ganga rejuvenation & restrained it from spending on any major project except maintenance work on the stretch from Haridwar to Kanpur. UP govt had told the NGT that as per estimates, at present 1382.36 MLD sewage is generated and only 300 MLD get treated in treatment plants. The UP Pollution Control Board on Oct 20 informed the Green Tribunal that a “flood” of multi-storeyed buildings have been constructed on the floodplains of Ganga and Yamuna over the years without devising any mechanism for waste disposal. It also told that floodplains have been encroached upon in Delhi, Noida and Greater Noida to build apartments and housing societies. Local authorities take money and grant them permission to discharge all the waste into the sewer lines. The court was also informed by advocates that there were almost lakh industries between Haridwar & Kanpur segment. However, according to CPCB there are only 1072 industries. The bench also asked it to file details about the existing STP and CETP and inform whether they were functional or not and also state whether they were capable of treating various pollutants, sewage and bacteria. According to a news report, mining on Ganga River bed in Uttarakhand continues, with approval from both centre and state govt. Meanwhile, there is news that Sonipat administration will inquire into the complaints of diversion of the Yamuna watersallegedly by two mining contractors near Tikola village in the district. A case has also been registered at the Murthal police station in this regard.
KarnatakaVillagers caution authorities over Malprabha pollution The releasing of sewage water to the Malaprabha river by Khanapur town panchayat authorities has been creating health related problems to the people in lower riparian villages. Irked with the problem, villagers have cautioned of locking town panchayat office if the releasing of effluent to river not stopped immediately.
Also seeProtecting 6 riversby S. VishwanathProtecting the ecology and the environment of the ranges will protect the rivers and fresh water. This will also help an orderly development of the place in a sustainable fashion. Unless an institution is created and armed with powers to manage this sensitive area we will see the gradual demise of a culture centered around water and the death of six rivers. The time to act is now and that would be water wisdom.
GujaratNHRC issues notices to govt over complaints of pollutionThe commission reacted to a complaint filed by Paryavaran Mitra, an NGO, pivotal in enforcing, environmental public hearing mandatory in the state. The commission has asked the state govt to file a reply within four weeks. The complaint submitted a CAG reports of 2015 and 2011 regarding Gujarat’s status of Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP). The reports stated that “None of the CETPs in Gujarat discharged their effluents as per the prescribed norms by the GPCB and wide variations were also noticed in the performance of CETPs.” Will NHRC do anything significant? Very doubtful, considering past examples, but helps highlight the issue.
DROUGHT OPTIONS
MaharashtraSolapur holds key to water-stressed MarathwadaThe patchy soil and water conservation efforts of the govt seem to have learnt nothing from the exemplary measures undertaken in Solapur district. Great to see this public appreciation for dynamic and innovative efforts by Tukaram Mundhe and his team in Solapur during 2015-16 drought.
DROUGHT 2016
Kerala Attappady in firm grip of droughtThis region in Palakkad has recorded 90% deficit rain in southwest monsoon. According meteorologists the area would not receive much rain even during the ensuing northwest monsoon. The perennial rivers Bhavani & Siruvani are a trickle now, much ahead of the summer months. The Kodukarampallam river has dried up. The heat wave has affected the cultivation of pulses & millets in Mulli, Kottathara, Sholayoor and Kadampara. Most tribal settlements face acute scarcity of drinking water. Most wells in eastern Attappady had turned dry. In others, the water level had depleted alarmingly. Palakkad district in Kerala, even with over 1000 mm of rainfall in monsoon, though with a deficit of huge 34%, is in grip of drought like situation with fast depleting dam stroages.
OdishaDrought manifests in 5 districtsThe specter of drought is looming over Deogarh, Sambalpur, Sonepur, Jharsuguda and Bolangir as these districts have received the less than average rainfall in the monsoon. In Bolangir district, paddy fields are wilting due to lack of water. A drought-like situation is already a reality in areas like Tureikela, Bangomunda, Muribahal, Saintala amongst others in Titlagarh subdivision of Bolangir district which have received less than 27% of the normal rainfall.
AndhraWorst ever drought hits APEven though cumulative rainfall from June 1 to October 19 deviated 17 per cent from the actual rainfall, which is considered normal, the number is likely to be higher than last year’s 359 mandals. While more than 500 mandals faced a drought-like situation till September, heavy rainfall in the second and third weeks, which resulted in flooding, brought down the number to 300-310.According to this report, Andhra is facing worst drought, worse than the last year. Some 370 mandals facing drought, but state is yet to declare drought.
DAMS
MaharashtraTadoba tigers under threat from Human dam projectConservationists have questioned the need for Human project after 33 years, especially when 20-22 major and minor irrigation projects like Gosikhurd, Ghodazari, Asolamendha and Nalleshwar have come up in Chandrapur district. Besides, the district has taken a lead in Jalyukt Shivar for which 41 cr have been approved. Another unjustified DAM threatens Another Tiger Reserve, this time is Human Dam in Wainganga-Godavari basin in Chandrapur district, threatening the Tadoba Andhari Tiger Reserve, hanging for 33 years thanks to contractor driven politicians-Engineer-bureaucrat lobby. The project will again be discussed at Maharashtra State Board of Wildlife on Oct 26, but basic documents are still not available to SBWL members.
MPDamning report on rehabilitation A massive scam involving the distribution of compensation to fake beneficiaries in MP is likely to crush the BJP’s hope of making political capital from the completion of the construction of the Sardar Sarovar Dam in Gujarat by Dec 2016. The compensation was meant for those who will be displaced when the dam’s height is raised. Gujarat’s chances of getting permission from the Supreme Court and Narmada Control Authority (NCA) to close the erected gates to store more water now appear bleak given that MP’s poor rehabilitation record has been completely exposed by a judicial inquiry. It is also strange that Gujarat minister is not bothered about the injustice to the affected people or the corruption and waste of public resources, he is only interested in getting permission to fill up the reservoir. Meanwhile Congress on Oct 19 alleged that the BJP govt in MP is in the thick of a “scam of monumental proportions” in the resettlement and rehabilitation of the oustees of the Sardar Sarovar project on the Narmada. It further said that PM Modi & the Gujarat BJP govt were compromising the interests of the peopleof Gujarat to save Shivraj Singh Chouhan’s BJP government in MP from the fallout of the resettlement and rehabilitation (R and R) scam there. Quoting the Justice Shravan Shankar Jha commission report, the party claimed that the funds meant for relief and rehabilitation of more than 40,000 families affected by the Sardar Sarovar project had been misappropriated.
INTER-STATE WATER DISPUTES
Krishna RowNo relook into allocation of water: TribunalThe tribunal pronounced its judgement on the litigation prompted by AP and TS arguing that Section 89 in the AP Reorganisation Act meant redistribution of Krishna water among all the four riparian States not just between them at New Delhi on Oct 19. In its verdict, the tribunal said Section 89 was not applicable to all four States but meant only for TS and AP. Further, it has asked TS and AP to come before it on December 14 with claims on sharing of water between the two out of the allocation made for combined AP by the tribunal already.
KarnatakaState faces water dispute issue with six states While water shortages and the need for drinking water and widening the area under irrigation are real concerns for Karnataka, the issues have been largely politicised and have become feeding trough for political parties in the basin regions, depending on which party is ruling and which is not in the respective states and the Centre. Karnataka has just gone through over a month long crisis over sharing the Cauvery waters with Tamil Nadu and Puducherry after the south-west monsoon in the state failed this year. Goa, where the Mahadayi is known as the Mandovi and is a lifeline for the state, has opposed this demand, citing ecological damage to the river. On the Krishna front, the new stat of Telangana asked for an additional 100 thousand million cubic feet (tmcft) of water for new irrigation projects.
INTER-LINKING OF RIVERS
KBLGetting clearances for Ken-Betwa will not be difficult: UmaThe Water Resources Minister keeps making pre-emptive statements about environment clearance to Ken Betwa link project, even talks about reconstitution of Expert Appraisal Committee, which provides a hint about what is the objective of EAC reconstitution.
FLOOD 2016
BiharState seeks Rs 4000 cr from Centre in flood damages At least 88 lakh people in 31 districts across the state were affected and 254 were killed, adding that 3.65 lakh hectares of land were submerged, causing extensive damage to crops. Out of the 31 flood-affected districts, 12 districts including Patna, Begusarai and Bhagalpur felt the maximum impact of the furious Ganga. The Ganga, which rose to a record level of 50.50 metres at Patna, over topped its banks at many points. The state had demanded Rs 14,846 crore when the Kosi embankment at Kusaha in Nepal had breached in 2008, causing untold miseries in all north Bihar districts and killing over 350 people. The then UPA government at the Centre had conceded a grant of Rs 1,000 crore.
IRRIGATION
ChhattisgarhVillagers protest against irrigation projectVillagers have come out in protest against the Gagar irrigation project in Chhattisgarh’s Balrampur district. The villagers said the special gram sabha convened for the project in different villages had refused the plan. Despite the protest, the district administration is allegedly planning to forcefully acquire the land for the project. Under the banner of Chhattisgarh Kisan Sabha and Adivasi Ekta Mahasabha, the villagers marched out a rally in Ambikapur, the divisional headquarters of Sarguja. A memorandum was given to the district authorities. The officials however did not comment on the development.
Centre Water ministry released ABIP first installment Union Water Ministry on Oct 21 announced to release of first installment of Rs. 1500 crore to the states as central assistance for 99 prioritized irrigation projects under Accelerated Irrigation Benefits Program (AIBP). This amount has been released for 50 projects in the states of Gujarat, Karnataka, MP, Maharashtra, Manipur, Odisha, Punjab, Rajasthan and Telangana.
Massive irregularities in Jharkhand irrigation projectsAccording to this Oct 20 news report from Prabhat Khabar there has been scams, delays and irregularities of monumental scale in several irrigation project in the State.
AGRICULTURE
MaharashtraDrought-stricken farmers plant thirstiest crop Without govt intervention to reset the revenue balance in favour of other crops, experts warn the sustained production of sugar cane will further deplete scarce water resources and leave the region prone to droughts. This could create social unrest stemming from the widening income gap between cane growers and other farmers. Govt hopes higher subsidies for pulses and oilseeds will change farming patterns. But industry critics said the pulse and oilseed MSP only exists on paper as the government never procures them aggressively like wheat or rice. Story explains why farmers prefer growing thirstiest crop in drought affected region & its implications.
On the other hand, despite satisfactory rainfall this monsoon, farmer suicides have not gone down in the State. As many as 2307 farmers have killed themselves till now, in 2016. The number is 45 more than number of suicides reported during the corresponding period in 2015. The suicide rate this year has been much higher than that in 2012, 2013 and 2014 the years of acute water scarcity. 1473, 1296 & 1981 farmers committed suicide in these years, respectively. 2015 had witnessed highest ever suicides – 3228.
There is one big article which initially seems to give an impression of a revolution happening in agriculture marketing in Maharashtra. The changes are indeed significant and it has all the seeds of a revolution, but so far the reformed markets outside APMC cater to only about 2% of agri market share, which shows that a lot more would need to be done before that potential becomes a reality. Pune, it seems at the hub of farmer-consumer market for vegetables and fruits, may be some Pune friends can throw more light.
Meanwhile, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare in its latest publication titled State of Indian Agriculture (2015-2016) seeks to present analysis of the recent growth and performance of the agriculture and allied sectorsand also to analyze the major emerging challenges.
SAND MINING
Tamil NaduVillagers protest against mining proposal in Kollidam riverA group of people from two villages in Lalgudi taluk came to the district collectorate in Trichy to submitting a memorandum opposing the proposed commencement of sand quarry in Kollidam river here on Monday. They alleged that illegal mining in Kollidam river upto 40 feet has affected their cultivation owing to depleting ground water table. They cautioned that it would become a threat for the newly constructed Trichy-Thanjavur bridge across Kollidam, if the govt permitted sand mining further.
WETLANDS & WATER BODIES
J&KFesh algae boom threatens Dal lakeThe single most cause of the Dal’s deterioration over the years is the blocking of its natural drainage system as a result of the filling in of the Nallah Mar in the 1970s. The stream which passed through downtown Srinagar was fed by Dal and helped in the circulation of the lake’s water. Loss of Nallah Mar choked Dal. The process of relocating Dal dwellers has been exceedingly slow. Despite all these measures, Dal is showing fewer signs of being on the road to recovering its old glory. The resurfacing of red algae has come as a reminder that something somewhere is seriously amiss.
RENEWABLE ENERGY
IndustryRenewable energy firms worry about back-down by power discomsNo PPAs are getting signed, signed PPAs are not being honoured, renewables are asked to back down, all negative signs for solar and wind developers, this affects even big players like Tata and Adani, among others. How will the advocacy for brining big hydro help in this scene? The scene is only going to further worsen in days to come.
REST OF THE WORLD
VietnamDam made floooding worseLocal officials are blaming the operators of the Ho Ho Hydroelectric Plant for making the deadly flooding in Vietnam’s Ha Tinh Province worse by suddenly releasing water held back by the dam. Flooding in Vietnam is being blamed for killing at least 25 people and destroying thousands of homes, as the country braced for even further destruction with typhoon Sarika closing in on the country. Sudden release of large quantity of water without information in the downstream area when the downstream areas were facing floods leads to avoidable destruction. Hope the investigation leads to truth.
ENVIRONMENT
NationalIndia headed for coal power overcapacityDespite its proactive stance on climate action, India continues to invest in increasing electricity capacity fired by coal, much of which may never be used, says a new report, but some experts disagree. This article rightly says that India is heading towards unnecessary building of thermal power plants at such huge costs and impacts. On the other hand according Crisil, nearly Rs 1.34 lakh crore worth of debton operational and under-construction power projects is at risk. Unnecessary and unproductive investments in power sector means increased NPAs (Non Performing assets), decreased credits and high risk debts. This can be easily avoided with wiser decisions, and not running after large hydro or coal power. Also see,Turning India’s surplus power into a boonThis report suggests ways to increase electricity consumption in India! However, the author seems quite well informed.
SANDRP BlogIMD’s River Basin Rainfall Maps Useful But Needs ImprovementWe have noticed during just concluded South West monsoon season that IMD has started a new and welcome feature in rainfall data reporting. The Data is available in maps, on daily, weekly and seasonal basis. We are not sure when this practice started, we noticed it only during 2016 monsoon season. This is most welcome development, since getting rainfall data at basin level is most appropriate and useful, since basin is the hydrological unit that will experience the impact of rainfall or lack of rainfall in the basin, in form of floods or droughts. There a number of limitations as of now. We hope IMD will take necessary steps to remove these limitations and improve the availability and access of basin wise rainfall maps and data in coming years.
Is there any justification for DESTRUCTION of Panna Tiger Reserve? Can we save our Natural Heritage like the Panna Tiger Reserve (PTR) from being destroyed in the name of baseless, questionable, non transparent, undemocratic and manipulated projects like Ken Betwa inter linking ? It will facilitate export of water from Bundelkhand to OUTSIDE Bundelkhand. Whatever little benefits are claimed, some of them are already available and much more can become available at much lower costs, faster and without destroying the Forests and Tiger Reserve. The project will actually lead to destruction of Ken catchment and hence the Ken River itself. Watch this FASCINATING, AWESOME story of tigers of PTR. This BBC film where Raghu Chandawat is the story teller and Pradip Kishen is lending his voice, tells the story of Tigers of Panna till 2003, it seems. Please watch and let us all try to save it from destruction that is now writ large in terms of Ken-Betwa Link Project (KBLP). One more short film by wildlife biologist Koustubh Sharma illustrates how the Daudhan Dam under KBLP will submerge and destroy the PTR.
Meanwhile, a new analysis of rainfall data reveals that monsoon shortages are growing in river basins with surplus water and falling in those with scarcities, raising questions about India’s Rs 11 lakh crore plan to transfer water from “surplus” to “deficit” basins. According to Himanshu Thakkar of SANDRP river basin interlinking should be considered only after exhausting the local potential for harvesting rain, recharging groundwater, watershed development, introducing better cropping patterns (non water-intensive crops) and methods (such as rice intensification), improving the soil moisture-holding capacity and saving and storing water. Raising alarm over significant increase in ground water use, increasing reliance and fast declining ground water table, he warns that inter-basin links would actually reduce groundwater recharge because forests would be destroyed, the river flow stopped and the local systems neglected.
Is there hope for India’s Environment from Mr Anil Dave? Most shocking statements from India’s environment Minister. He says let us do Ken Betwa link when the project has NONE of the statutory clearances from his own ministries. The independent committees are yet to appraise the project and yet he is saying: “This Ken-Betwa river link we should do it and have an impact assessment after five years. If it is good, then great, if not they don’t go for other linkages.” Is there any hope for India’s environment? As he says, YE SAB CHALTA HAI!!
Op-EdNGT failed its mandate by allowing AOL eventThis is such an amazing editorial on the issue of destruction of floodplain by Art of Living, whose behaviour is brazen, but predictable, it says! So amazingly forthright, it says “ Far more unfortunate, however, is the manner in which the NGT appears to have conducted itself in this affair. It is a sad commentary on the state of environmental governance n the country that its premier green body”, NGT, “ has to prevaricate on its earlier order”. It concludes. NGT failed to protect such an ecologically sensitive area. It is deeply disturbing that the country’s apex environmental tribunal allowed itself to be pressured and intimidated. Salutes to the Author of this forthright editorial! Meanwhile, the committee of experts, appointed by Green has found that the “entire floodplain area used for the main event site” has been “completely destroyed” causing “invisible loss of biodiversity” that “may never be able to return”. In its 45 page report, submitted to the NGT on July 28, the seven-member panel, said “the entire floodplain area used for the main event site, i.e. between the DND flyover and Barapullah drain (on the right bank of river Yamuna) has been completely destroyed, completely destroyed not simply destroyed. The ground is now totally levelled, compacted and hardened, totally devoid of water bodies or depressions, and almost completely devoid of any vegetation (except a few large cattails at the base of of the DND flyover)”. On the contrary AOL alleged that NGT appointed committee is biased, unscientific and lacks credibility.
In absence of clear and strict laws to define the rivers zone and demarcate flood plains, our rivers are increasingly becoming subject to exploitation. When the river spaces of our National River Ganga & Yamuna River which flow through National Capital are not well protected, then the plight of other rivers across country can be understood.
This week, there are two news reports which again are highlighting this cause. Interestingly in both cases, legal fight is going on in green tribunal which indirectly deals with the issue though with no success so far. In fist case, NGT has directed Govt. of Uttarakhand todemarcate floodplainsof Ganga river from its origin in Gomukh till Roorkee, a 65-km long stretch in the state. The tribunal has posted the matter for the next hearing on Oct 20 and asked the state government to submit its compliance report by then. The bench also sought a report on the total number of hotels on the 65-km stretch from the govt. The green panel allowed the state govt to take the help of Roorkee-based National Institute of Hydrology for identification of flood plains. Construction on flood plains and inside river zones is a sure invitation to disaster such as Kedar Nath Floods in 2013 when human made infrastructures erected very much inside river zones were raised down like sand dunes by enraged rivers. It is sad and even more worrisome that we have learnt nothing from such events.
In second incident Govt. of Uttar Pradesh has drawn green tribunal’s ire over constructions in floodplains. The apex court for environmental issues, expressed its dissatisfaction over the manner in which State Govt filed its report on the distance of various real estate projects from the Yamuna flood plain zone in the city. Coming down heavily in the state govt and various Agra authorities, Agra Development Authority (ADA) & irrigation department, it stated that “authorities were expected to act fairly and judicially while complying with its directions.” The tribunal appointed registrar general Mukesh Kumar Gupta as local commissioner and asked him to file a correct position of flood plains and the distances of the various projects. Meanwhile, ADA has been asked to produce the original records before the tribunal on the next date of hearing, Aug19.
Floods & floodplains are integral part of a river eco-system. Both has essential roleto play in smooth functioning of multiple ecological processes that takes place throughout the journey of a river. It is abused of floodplains that our cities are facing flood threats. It is surprising to see how govts have so far failed in protection of flood plain.
With incidents of excess rainfall, cloud burst & land slides happening at increased frequency, it is time to define our river zone and flood plain clearly in the own interest of human being.
SANDRP BLOG Aug 06, ILR meeting is no dialogueWhile dialogue is necessary and welcome in any democracy, the meeting that was organized on Aug 06 at Constitutional Club is certainly not the right step in almost every sense. We hope MoWR and those who gather at the constitution club today will deliberate on these issues and resolve to correct them before a dialogue can really begin on the issue of ILR, and in fact Rivers. SANDRP coordinator was invited at this meeting on ILR being held at Constitution Club at 4 pm today as a speaker, but have decided to decline the invite, as elaborated in the note here. Please help us spread the word. Feedback is welcome.As was expected, Minister Uma Bharti reiterated that the Ken Betwa Link project will be implemented, even though the project has none of the clearances as yet! The reporter should have mentioned that.
SANDRP 